` Holocaust. Truth about Babyn Yar. (Part four)

© Tatiana TUR (USA), “Vechirniy Kyiv”(“Evening Kyiv”), March 16th, 1996

 

Holocaust. Truth about Babyn Yar.

Documental research

(Part four)

 

It is worth to remember for Levitas about one more of the many contradictions in the evidence of the “eyewitnesses” and “those who escaped”. Almost all Jews who escaped in two years after the “slaughter” in Babyn Yar witnessed that in the last days of September and the first days of  October 1941 they escaped from execution, hiding naked in ravines. They told that at that time it was so hot and dry, that one Jewish woman had to give to drink her saliva to the bare baby because of lack of water. In the article of I.Levitas we read: “One woman told, that she and her female friend (they were 12 years old) were given a jar with water and cotton wool plugs, they were asked to moisten lips of children, who were with them.

 

    Pity for kids, they want to drink, men said.

 

They day was warm, children really wanted to drink and female friends carefully moistened kids’ lips. Then it was found out that the poison was in the jars, and soon after that kids died. The woman remembers that it was the second of October – her birthday”.

However, this evidence is impossible to coordinate with the recollection of the general Bagramyan, where it is said about the weather on the 29th of September: “It was raining. Cars went into a skid, sticking in the mud. Fascists stopped the stuck cars”. (Page 377).

Germans wrote the same in the daily writings (Kriegstagebuch), that in this time a “bottomless bog” was standing in the environs of Kyiv, and about the weather it was mentioned:

·        “The 28th of September: cold, cloudy, no rain. The seven-day great fire in Kyiv is stopping”.

 

·        “The 29th of September: it rained all day long, roads turned into sludge. In the evening it cleared up away, it became cold. The fire in Kyiv was almost coped with”.

 

·        “The 30th of September: it snows and rains. The roads are becoming worse”.

 

·        “The 1st of October: it is wet, the roads in the environs of the 48th division of artillery turned into the bottomless bog”.

 

·        “The 2nd of October: the sky is cloudless, the weather is autumnal. Roads are getting dry”.

 

·        “The 3rd of October: the sky is cloudless, the weather is autumnal. Most of roads got dry”.

And here some questions arise:

·        How did Asia Nesgort and other “who escaped” survived being naked in snags with babies on hands in the ravine, residing out in the rain and snow, when there were no dry leaves on the ground?

·        How did “escaped” I.Pronicheva could depose in the Darmstadt court that during this four days she died from the thirst and heat?

In our opinion, I.Levitas with at least a little bit of impartiality should give credence more to Germans and Bagramyan, than the “escaped” congeners.

·        Why did the clerk of Wehrmacht would lie about the weather?

·        And even if it was so, then why the Soviet war chroniclers (Bagramyan based his reminiscence upon their records) had to copy Germans in the lies?

In the brochure about Babyn Yar that was published in 1991 by O.Shlayen and I.Levitas,

·        “Escaped” Raisa Dashkevich for some reason or other mentioned that in the day of military shootings “it was cold”.

·        On the other hand, the juveniles, who gave to drink the poisoned water to the Jewish children, mention that it was “warm”. How can these discordant testimonies be brought together to the one truthful?

And why did the mothers, seeing that their Jewish children were dying because young Jewish women had poisoned them, didn’t protest? A critical person will never believe such fibs of “those who escaped”.

(To be continued)